best hardcore band EVER

i started this thread hoping to get some legit answers and actually have legit conversation about it

wow was i ever disappointed

i never asked what people's favorite bands are.....

i asked what people think is the best band in hardcore. my favorite band is not even close to being the best band in hardcore.

You have to understand that everything we have is meaningless

I think a discussion like this could be possible, but you can't just ask the question "What is the best hardcore band ever?" Everyone would probably need to agree on a specific set of guidelines/parameters for discussion to make it at least somewhat objective.

this thread is all sorts of AWKWARD

no guts no glory

I'm with Burns on this.
I'd rather pick Modern Life Is War or American Nightmare than Cro-Mags.

CHUUUUUUUUUUUNKS

vango wrote:

I'm with Burns on this.
I'd rather pick Modern Life Is War or American Nightmare than Cro-Mags.

american nightmare/gotg is actually totally unlistenable imho




no contest

^ will not argue

Storm of Damnation wrote:

vango wrote:

I'm with Burns on this.
I'd rather pick Modern Life Is War or American Nightmare than Cro-Mags.

american nightmare/gotg is actually totally unlistenable imho

mitchhardordie wrote:

dancehardordie wrote:

Exit Wounds wrote:

Not to say title fight is bad or anything, but doesn't that band have like two 7"s and a demo? ..I think a band needs a little more material than that to even be considered for best band ever.

especially when their style is completely adopted from another band... bad seed is better

how can you even compare bad seed to title fight?

they sound absolutely nothing alike.....

not to mention title fight are not even a hardcore band. fuck

because they are pretty much the same band... 3 same members. fuck

that dude from american nightmare needs a real arm. someone give this man a hand!

ZZZZZZZING

waitwaitwait... i just reread this thread from the beginning.

someone said allegiance? life long tragedy? MLIW? lights out? go it alone (and i actually enjoy material by both LO and GIA)??
what the fuuuuuuuck, come on guys. none of these bands are more than a decade old and are literally all myspace top friends with each other.

i know you weren't, i was jus sayin. in regards to local bands, even the skitzos were important to me. tehy were part of my youth. i'd get to rage with my friends every two weeks and see the skitzos. shit was the best. i miss that band more than i can explain.
die young ruled. i agree they were an important band. good dudes.

dude, the skitzos circa spring/summer 2006. best times of my life.

RATKING666 wrote:

dude, the skitzos circa spring/summer 2006. best times of my life.

yeah, literally . the skitzos around that time made for one of the best times of my life, despite a lot of shitty stuff i was going through at the time.

ahahaha, passive-aggressive melodic hardcore is such a good term.

everyone just sit back and listen to the germs anthology straight through once please.

melody will always be more interesting, sorry dudes.

listen to born against

This thread is wack. but my opinion sucks too!

I'd have to say DK kicked my ass. And still kicks my ass. And Jello changed my life/stage presence/attitude... everything. His flamboyant nature...his daym good looks... good ol' 80's hardcore punk.

I still say this all the time and people think I'm an idiot. Fuck TTIT!!!

DK are one of the best bands ever, let alone within punk!
ttit?

Integrity.